Zero Tolerance



"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." — Benjamin Franklin
 


Zero Tolerance Resources


Zero-Tolerance and School Discipline Policies

See More Resources


The Rutherford Institute has handled many cases defending the constitutional rights of school-aged children unnecessarily punished for violating unreasonable zero tolerance rules in schools. We have also assisted teachers and employees who have been unfairly punished under these sweeping policies.

Today America faces many frightening realities. The mainstream media is saturated with stories of shootings, rampant drug use amongst youth, and the ever-present threat of terrorism. But in the pursuit to establish and maintain safety, many of our governments and institutions go too far. Indeed, the policies of these institutions and agencies often infringe on our constitutional rights and liberties. We must never fail to balance today’s dangers in schools, malls, and other public places with the timeless and essential ideals written and preserved in our Bill of Rights. By refusing to consider each individual's personal history and the intentions that inspired their actions, zero tolerance policies deny the unique worth and dignity of every person.

The Rutherford Institute is devoted to the ideal of freedom and common sense. Childish behavior and youthful misjudgments must not be punished egregiously, but rather in the context of the learning environment.



Our Recent Work in Zero Tolerance


Public School Agrees to Rescind Suspension, Wipe Record of 4-Year-Old Pre-Schooler Who Was Handcuffed, Shackled and Transported to Police Station

Rutherford Institute Defends 4-Year-Old Pre-Schooler Who Was Handcuffed, Shackled and Transported to Police Station for Allegedly Acting Up in Class

Victory: Federal Court Gives Green Light to Lawsuit Over Wrongful Suspension of Lacrosse Players for Possession of Deadly Weapons (Penknife, Lighter)

Federal Court Dismisses Case of Chicago School Teacher Who Was Suspended, Accused of Weapons Possession for Lesson on Wrenches, Pliers

Victory: Officials Agree to Clear Record, Retrain Employees After 11-Year-Old is Suspended Under ‘Dangerous Weapons’ Policy for Turning in Toy Gun

Maryland School Claims Immunity in Lawsuit Over Wrongful Suspension of Lacrosse Players for Possession of Deadly Weapons (Penknife, Lighter)

Zero Tolerance: Chicago School Officials Suspend 11-Year-Old Boy Under ‘Dangerous Weapons’ Policy for Voluntarily Turning in Non-Firing Toy Gun

VICTORY: School Officials to Lift Suspension from 10-Year-Old Who Shot Imaginary Arrow at Pennsylvania Elementary School


Commentary on Zero Tolerance Issues


Handcuffs, Leg Shackles and Tasers: The New Face of Punishment in the Public Schools

Arrested Development: The Criminalization of America’s Schoolchildren

Zero Tolerance Policies: Are the Schools Becoming Police States?

Teaching Totalitarianism in the Public Schools